• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Top Picks for Him

Just a Men Blog and Trusted Reviews

  • Categories
    • Gifts and Lists
    • Health and Beauty
    • Power and Hand Tools
    • Shoes and Boots
  • Product Reviews
You are here: Home / Archives for beard balm vs beard oil

Beard Butter vs. Beard Balm vs. Beard Oil (What Is The Best?)

December 18, 2020 by Jan Murphy 1 Comment

It’s time to talk about the very new beard products. The truth of the matter is that they may be new. But they’re also incredibly helpful. To men who love growing their beards in various styles! So in this post, I’m going to discuss the three most well-received oil-based beard products. That is the comparison between beard butter vs. beard balm vs. beard oil.

Beard butter, balm, and oil are very helpful assets. All three have a sacred place in every man’s beard arsenal. However, don’t just assume that all “beard” labeled products are worth your money.

There are many options out there packed with anti-androgens. That is actually detrimental when it comes to beard upkeep and growth.

How about I compare two different beard products at one time? This way you’ll gain a better understanding of the specifics of each option. And with that, I’ve also decided to list the best products. Like the best beard butter, beard balm, and beard oil. So are you ready?

But before that, let’s find out the commonalities between the three.

Beard Butter vs. Beard Balm vs. Beard Oil: Similarities

beard-butter-vs-beard-balm-vs-beard-oil-comparison

Photo credit: oakcitybeardcompany.com

If you want to know the differences, you’ve got to understand the similarities too. If they exist! And in this case, they definitely do.

Different products are equipped with different kinds of ingredients. So it becomes a little difficult to point them out specifically. But one thing is for sure though. That all these ingredients contain essential oils and carrier oils. (DIY Beard Oil)

Other common denominators in butters, balms, and oils include:

  • Beeswax
  • Cocoa butter
  • Shea butter
Maestro's Classic Beard Butter Wisemen's Blend

Maestro's Classic Beard Butter Wisemen's Blend

BEST DEAL Beard Balm with Argan Oil & Mango Butter

BEST DEAL Beard Balm with Argan Oil & Mango Butter

Honest Amish - Classic Beard Oil

Honest Amish - Classic Beard Oil

Check Price
Check Price
Check Price

Now you should know that such products are crafted for beard growth. When in fact you can use them on your skin and head hair as well.

Butters, balms, and oils help tremendously for the transformation of your stubble into a beard. The beard-growing process tends to make the hair excessively dry. And this ends up causing a lot of irritation.

So at such times, any one of the three products goes a long way in making the journey more comfortable. And by that, I mean itch-free!

  • Beard balms are more useful for facial hair. Thanks to the presence of more beeswax. This means you should not apply too much of it on your skin. As beeswax has the ability to clog pores!
  • On the other hand, beard butters and oils are perfect for skin application. Since they don’t contain excessive or any beeswax.

However, don’t think that a beard balm is not good for the skin. Or that you should strictly avoid using it on the skin!

What I mean to say is that it offers a greater chance of clogging your pores. With that in place, let me tell you that carrier oils also possess that same ability. So simply make sure that you don’t use too much of any one option on your skin.

Are we clear about this? Time to move on!

5 things I wish I knew back then: Beginner Beard Tips

play

Beard Butter vs. Beard Balm vs. Beard Oil: Comparison

Beard Butter vs. Beard Balm

beard-butter-vs-beard-balm

Photo credit: livebearded.com

I’m discussing the beard butter vs. beard balm topic first. Let’s start with the latter.

A beard balm product consists of a combination of beeswax and carrier oils. The one praiseworthy benefit here is that it controls flyaway hairs. The balm version is able to keep the beard shaped. Simply by providing the much-needed firm hold.

The firmness is the most useful for shorter beards (Man’s Guide to Beards). The only downside to this is that a balm contains beeswax, which makes the beard stiff or hard.

So when it comes to application, be mindful and use very little. No wonder beard balms are available in smaller sizes like 2 ounces. Such as the Viking Revolution Beard Balm with Argan Oil & Mango Butter.

Now it’s time to talk about beard butter. Good beard butters are packed with shea butter and carrier oils. 

One such popular option is the Maestro’s Classic Beard Butter Wisemen’s Blend. It offers all the hydration your hair demands. To promote healthier and fuller growth!

Here’s another thing about shea butter. It absorbs into your beard easily, which provides instant results.

Beard butters like these act as deep conditioners that control and soften the hair. At the same time, they offer a medium to light hold. This is great for taming flyaway hairs. And also for shaping them!

Beard Butter vs. Beard Balm: What to Pick?

Maestro's Classic Beard Butter Wisemen's Blend

Maestro's Classic Beard Butter Wisemen's Blend

BEST DEAL Beard Balm with Argan Oil & Mango Butter

BEST DEAL Beard Balm with Argan Oil & Mango Butter

Check Price on Amazon.com
Check Price on Amazon.com

The matter is quite simple here.

Go for the beard balm if you wish to have more hold and control.

But if deep conditioning is your priority, I would suggest the beard butter. And to answer the question, does beard butter help beard growth? YES, it surely does.

Here’s another important part of the beard butter vs. beard balm comparison. With regards to the products mentioned!

​

Maestro’s Classic Beard Butter Wisemen’s Blend

Viking Revolution Beard Balm with Argan Oil & Mango Butter

Type

Beard butter

Beard balm

Size

8 ounces

2 ounces

Shea Butter

Yes

Yes

Carrier Oils

Yes

No

Essential Oils

3 essential oils

2 essential oils

Beeswax

No

Yes

Best For

Deep conditioning

Hold and control

Beard Butter vs. Beard Oil

beard-butter-vs-beard-oil

Photo credit: manlinesskit.com

It’s time for another heavyweight comparison between beard butter vs. beard oil. The former is quite popular among bearded men. The latter is a more recent creation. However, it’s not in the least bit any less effective and competitive. So let’s talk about that first.

Beard oil ingredients include carrier oils and essential oils. The carrier moisturizes and hydrates your skin and hair. Along with reducing itch and dandruff! And essential oils are responsible for the delicious fragrance. Such as vanilla, citrus, sandalwood, cedar, and pine.

In the case of Honest Amish Classic Beard Oil, the product contains seven different essential oils.

The one takeaway benefit of beard oil is moisturizing the beard and maintaining its health. To boost hair growth and eliminate beard dandruff and itch!

As for beard butter, the ingredients are shea butter, essential oils, and carrier oils. The shea butter takes care of deep conditioning. But in the Maestro’s Classic Beard Butter Wisemen’s Blend, there’s also mango butter. Along with jojoba oil and argan oil! These ingredients combine to help you achieve perfection.

The benefits of beard butter are pretty much out there. The product does an excellent job when it comes to deep conditioning. It keeps the hair healthy and soft. While also providing the hold your beard demands during the process!

Beard Butter vs. Beard Oil: What to Pick?

Maestro's Classic Beard Butter Wisemen's Blend

Maestro's Classic Beard Butter Wisemen's Blend

Honest Amish - Classic Beard Oil

Honest Amish - Classic Beard Oil

Check Price on Amazon.com
Check Price on Amazon.com

Should you choose the best beard oil over the best beard butter? Or the other way round?

The oil benefits the skin in such a way that it prevents irritation. And the butter is perfect for making your beard feel and look fuller, softer, and healthier.

If you want a side by side comparison of beard butter vs. beard oil, here it is:

​

Maestro’s Classic Beard Butter Wisemen’s Blend

Honest Amish Classic Beard Oil​

Type

Beard butter

Beard oil

Size

8 ounces

2 ounces

Shea Butter

Yes

Yes

Carrier Oils

Yes

Yes

Essential Oils

3 essential oils

7 essential oils

Beeswax

No

No

Best For

Deep conditioning

Preventing irritation

Beard Balm vs. Beard Oil

beard-balm-vs-beard-oil

Photo credit: worthyandspruce.com

How to settle the debate between beard balm vs. beard oil? Well, to be honest, it’s not such a conundrum. And commonly asked questions like how often to use beard balm? 

Or where to buy beard balm? The answers to these queries are also discussed below. But let’s start with beard oil for a better understanding.

Beard oil is a product that contains both carrier and essential oils. It nourishes the skin and hair to make the beard soft and healthy. Along with giving it an irresistible fragrance!

As you already know, the Honest Amish Classic Beard Oil is an excellent choice here. It reaches your skin underneath. To eliminate dandruff and itch!

Moving on to beard balm, this product is equipped with just essential oils. Along with butter and beeswax of course! So expect the Viking Revolution Beard Balm with Argan Oil & Mango Butter to do what exactly?

To condition your hair and offer a firm enough beard hold. It allows you to have more control over your hair. While also maintaining the natural look!

And the best part about the balm is that you can use it on a daily basis.

Beard Balm vs. Beard Oil: What to Pick?

BEST DEAL Beard Balm with Argan Oil & Mango Butter

BEST DEAL Beard Balm with Argan Oil & Mango Butter

Honest Amish - Classic Beard Oil

Honest Amish - Classic Beard Oil

Check Price on Amazon.com
Check Price on Amazon.com

Let me state it simply.

Pick the beard oil if…

  • You want your beard to feel soft and nourished.
  • You want to reduce itch and dandruff.
  • Your goal is to grow a fuller, shinier beard.

As for the beard balm, opt for that if…

  • You’re fond of irresistible scents.
  • Nourishment from within is a primary concern.
  • You wish to enjoy complete control over the beard look.

Needless to say, both products help in achieving different results. Beard oil may be a more conventional choice. But it’s not as effective as beard balm when it comes to deep conditioning.

While one boosts beard growth, the other encourages a controllable environment. The former is the job of beard oil. And the latter is brought upon by beard balm.

Here’s a quick comparison table of beard balm vs. beard oil:

​

Viking Revolution Beard Balm with Argan Oil & Mango Butter

Honest Amish Classic Beard Oil​

Type

Beard balm

Beard oil

Size

2 ounces

2 ounces

Shea Butter

Yes

Yes

Carrier Oils

No

Yes

Essential Oils

2 essential oils

7 essential oils

Beeswax

Yes

No

Best For

Hold and control

Preventing irritation

Beard Butter vs. Beard Balm vs. Beard Oil: Final Say

beard-butter-vs-beard-balm-vs-beard-oil

Photo credit: thebeardedbastard.com

This brings me to end of the debate between Beard Butter vs. Beard Balm vs. Beard Oil.

Once again, allow me to list the three contenders here:

  • Maestro’s Classic Beard Butter Wisemen’s Blend
  • Viking Revolution Beard Balm with Argan Oil & Mango Butter
  • Honest Amish Classic Beard Oil

I have discussed everything you need to know about each product. And I have also compared each one with the other. So now you might be able to differentiate between them. And I’m hoping that you’re also able to choose one option. After all, my aim is to make this easier for you.

However, if you’re still confused, let me help for the last time:

Pick beard butter if you care the most about deep conditioning the beard.

Pick beard balm for more hold and control of your beard.

And pick beard oil if you want to prevent the irritation often accompanied by beard growth.

So have I done justice to the topic at hand? If you have any feedback or tips to offer, please get to the comments section right below.

Related Tips and Tricks:

  1. Pro Gainer vs. Serious Mass (What Is The Best Weight Gainer?)
  2. Pomade vs. Fiber vs. Paste (What is the Best Hairstyling Product?)
  3. Work Boots vs. Hiking Boots (You Need to Know This!)
  4. Straight Razor vs Safety Razor - How Long Does a Safety Razor Blade Last?
  5. Top 7 Benefits of Shaving with a Straight Razor (#7 Is The Most Persuasive)

Sources:

  • Beard Balm vs Beard Butter
  • Beard Oil vs Beard Butter
  • Beard Balm vs Oil vs Butter: Does It Matter?

Filed Under: Health and Beauty Tagged With: beard balm amazon, beard balm before and after, beard balm or oil for short beard, beard balm use, beard balm vs beard oil, beard butter before and after, beard butter recipe, beard butter vs beard balm, beard butter vs beard oil, Beard Butter vs. Beard Balm vs. Beard Oil, beard butter whipped, beard oil, beard oil for short beards, beard oil or balm first, best beard butter, best beard oil, does beard balm help beard grow, does beard butter help beard growth, honest amish beard balm, honest amish beard balm recipe, how to use beard balm, when to use beard oil

Our Best Men’s Underwear Selections

Top Posts & Pages

  • Top 10 Best Panties for Men You’ll Find Are So Popular (2020 Reviews)
    Top 10 Best Panties for Men You’ll Find Are So Popular (2020 Reviews)
  • The 20 Best Jockstrap for Vasectomy You’ll Find The Most Supportive
    The 20 Best Jockstrap for Vasectomy You’ll Find The Most Supportive
  • The Best Men’s Underwear with Pouch for Balls You Need to Know About (2020 Reviews)
    The Best Men’s Underwear with Pouch for Balls You Need to Know About (2020 Reviews)
  • Pro Gainer vs. Serious Mass (What Is The Best Weight Gainer?)
    Pro Gainer vs. Serious Mass (What Is The Best Weight Gainer?)
  • Top 20 Anti-Chafing Underwear for Men (#1 is the Best Pick) – 2020 Reviews
    Top 20 Anti-Chafing Underwear for Men (#1 is the Best Pick) – 2020 Reviews

Our Best Men’s Underwear Selections

TopPicksforHim.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc., or its affiliates. Additionally, TopPicksforHim.com participates in various other affiliate programs, and we sometimes get a commission through purchases made through our links. We do not specifically market to children under 13.

Social

Follow me on:
  • About Me
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Police
  • Contact

Copyright © 2021 · Aspire Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in